News & Multimedia

Hendrick Wins Last Appeal

Courtesy of Speed.com

In a stunning reversal of fortune, NASCAR chief appellate officer John Middlebrook today overturned the critical portions of NASCAR penalties levied against the No. 48 Hendrick Motorsports team for modified C-posts discovered during pre-qualifying inspection for the Daytona 500.

The means Jimmie Johnson’s crew chief, Chad Knaus, and car chief, Ron Malec, will not face six-week suspensions and Johnson will not lose 25 points. In Knaus’ case, the $100,000 fine still stands, the only part of the penalty left intact.

Asked why the ruling was overturned, NASCAR spokesman Kerry Tharp said, “I’m sure the chief appellate officer has his reasons for doing that. He heard both sides. It’s his prerogative to make those types of decisions and that’s part of the process. ... The NASCAR rulebook provides for this process in our sport and we believe in our rulebook.”

The ruling was a huge victory for Hendrick Motorsports in its second and final appeal. Last week, the National Stock Car Racing Commission denied the first appeal and today was Hendrick’s last chance, and the final appeal paid big dividends.

Instantly, Johnson moves from 17th to 11th in points, and his team will not be without its two top leaders, which would have been a significant loss over the next six races.

NASCAR officials said the last time a points penalty was overturned on appeal in the Sprint Cup Series came in October 2005, when Michael Waltrip and Dale Earnhardt Inc. were fined driver and owner points after Waltrip made an “inappropriate gesture by the driver during a televised broadcast.”

Today’s ruling dwarfs those from 2005, however.

Team owner Rick Hendrick and Knaus both said that the team provided Middlebrook with extensive documentation that the No. 48, as configured at Daytona, already had passed inspection and raced at all four restrictor-plate races in 2011 and had passed inspection again at the NASCAR R&D Center in Concord, N.C. in January 2012.

Middlebrook was not available for comment.

“I’m glad this is over,” said Hendrick. “It’s been a long 30 days, I guess. I appreciate the fact that we had the opportunity to present all the facts. I’m happy with the outcome to see the points reinstated and Chad reinstated and our other guys, too. I would have liked to have the fine gone, too, because I think there was no reason for any kind of penalty.”

Hendrick was adamant about the legality of the car.

“I felt from the very beginning that we were clearly by the rulebook, within the guidelines, and the car had been seen multiple times, and raced everywhere we raced in 2011,” said Hendrick. “... I believe so hard and so much in the facts.”

The main fact, in this case, apparently was that the car, as it was presented prior to Daytona 500 qualifying, was signed off on multiple times.

“I don’t know how, looking at the rulebook, if an official says the car is right, the car is right,” said Hendrick. “The car goes through the (NASCAR) Tech Center and it passes, it passes. If we have a signed affidavit that says it hasn’t been touched, it hasn’t been touched. So, what’s the issue?”

The original penalty ruling was that the No. 48 car was found to be in violation of Sections 12-1 (actions detrimental to stock car racing); 12-4J (any determination by NASCAR officials that race equipment used in the event does not conform to NASCAR rules detailed in Section 20 of the rule book or has not been approved by NASCAR prior to the event); and 20-2.1E (if in the judgment of NASCAR officials, any part or component of the car not previously approved by NASCAR that has been installed or modified to enhance aerodynamic performance will not be permitted – unapproved car body modifications).

Knaus and Malec originally were each suspended for six Sprint Cup races and Knaus was fined $100,000.

Johnson and car owner Jeff Gordon were penalized with the loss of 25 driver and 25 owner points, respectively.

But those penalties are now history and the team will face no sanctions other than the Knaus fine.

“Nobody enjoys this,” said Hendrick. “I think today, by taking the time and going piece by piece, date by date, you can see that there’s no ill-intent on our part. We were clearly, I felt like — by the rulebook, we were clearly approved.”

Show More Show Less
Now Viewing
Hendrick Wins Last Appeal
 
Hendrick Wins Last Appeal
In a stunning reversal of fortune, NASCAR chief appellate officer John Middlebrook today overturned the critical portions of NASCAR penalties levied against the No. 48 Hendrick Motorsports team for modified C-posts discovered during pre-qualifying inspection for the Daytona 500.
Read More
Related Media
Indiana College Preparatory School
 
IMS Sponsoring Two Students in Unique Work-Study Program
The Indianapolis Motor Speedway is partnering with Indianapolis’ Providence Cristo Rey College Preparatory School in Indianapolis on its acclaimed program that introduces students to professional work environments.
Read More
Kyle Busch
 
No Catching Dominant Busch at Prolonged Brickyard
Never before had a driver in this NASCAR race been so dominant, but the defending Sprint Cup Series and Brickyard 400 champion had to endure a series of four restarts beginning on Lap 153 that prolonged a 160-lap race 10 additional laps at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
Read More
Jeff Gordon and Tony Stewart
 
Two Hoosiers, One Final Memorable Moment at The Brickyard
Tony Stewart couldn’t imagine a better farewell, aside from winning, than to invite Jeff Gordon for one more 2.5-mile drive at the track that has meant so much to both NASCAR rivals. Sunday was supposed to be Stewart’s final Brickyard 400. Last year was supposed to be Gordon’s swan song.
Read More
Kyle Busch
 
Kyle Busch Wins 2016 Crown Royal 400 at the Brickyard
The Joe Gibbs Racing driver dominated Sunday’s Crown Royal presents the Combat Wounded Coalition 400 at the Brickyard, leading 149 of 170 laps from the pole and surviving four restarts late in his No. 18 Skittles Toyota. He joined Jimmie Johnson (2008-09) as the only driver to repeat in the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series race at Indianapolis.
Read More
Jimmie Johnson
 
Brickyard Hopefully The Elixir for Struggling Hendrick Motorsports
That’s what happens when an entire four-car team synonymous with NASCAR success sputters in an improbable slump. Owner Rick Hendrick’s four cars have failed to finish in the top 10 in the past three races entering Sunday’s Crown Royal presents the Combat Wounded Coalition 400 at the Brickyard.
Read More
Items 1 - 5 of 700
Reserve one of our hospitality suites for your next event!
To start planning your event at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway please fill out our Information Request Form or contact Laura Wyamn at (317) 492-8557 or email at lwyman@brickyard.com.
Latest Tweets
Less than 2 hours! Tune in at 9pm ET on @NBCSN to catch finish of the #Firestone600 from @TXMotorSpeedway! https://t.co/WD3FDOXHVP
about 60 minutes ago